Texas

Why did the man Alice Sebold help exempt the prisoner?Tom Leonard asks

The acclaimed novelist Alice Sebold was a freshman at Syracuse University in northern New York when she was raped at Knife Point in May 1981.

Horrible trials will define her writing career.

Her most famous novel, The Lovely Bones, which later became a feature film starring Saoirse Ronan, is about a girl who was raped and murdered.

And Sebald’s memoir, Lucky, cultivated the same shocking literary ridges, and the cover declared:’The girl was killed and demolished in the tunnel where I was raped. I heard this story from the police. In comparison, they said I was lucky.

Critics made a fuss about her unwavering portrayal of rape, her determination to regain life from an attacker, and “the courage to speak indescribable.”

The terrifying test of acclaimed novelist Alice Sebold will define her writing career in her most famous novel, The Lovely Bones, published in 2002.

The inspiration for a glittering literary career seemed perfectly correct, so she should be able to use the tragedy that might have ruined her life.

The only problem seems to be that it ruined another innocent life — the life of a man she identified in court as her attacker.

On Monday, a Syracuse judge reversed Anthony Broadwater’s conviction at the request of a prosecutor who admitted that the first trial was seriously flawed.

Broadwater lawyers pointed out that Sebald first identified another man in a police identification parade.

They also claimed that the prosecution relied on some kind of microscopic hair analysis uncovered by forensic scientists.

Ironically, despite decades of Broadwater fighting to clear his name, the success of his appeal was primarily the producer of the film version of the pre-produced memoirs of Sebald. May be due to. He noticed a contradiction between the script of the movie and her book.

Broadwater, 61, sobbed in court because prosecutor William Fitzpatrick said: It doesn’t cut it. This should never have happened. ”

Anthony Broadwater, 61, responds to Judge Gordon Coffey's overturning the conviction of a 40-year-old rape who illegally put him in state prison with Alice Sebold's rape. ..

Anthony Broadwater, 61, responds to Judge Gordon Coffey’s overturning the conviction of a 40-year-old rape who illegally put him in state prison with Alice Sebold’s rape. ..

Sebald, 58, did not comment on this decision, said her publisher, Scrivener. He added that there were no plans to update the contents of the memoirs covering the arrest and conviction of her alleged attacker.

In a 2003 interview, she said: So, as soon as they told me it, I knew I would. I stared hard at him and kept an eye on him, so he turned his back and looked down.

Broadwater said he sympathizes with the author “true and strongly.” “Something happened, but I wasn’t that person,” he said.

“I pray that Mr. Sebald will come forward and apologize, saying,’Hey, I made a serious mistake.'”

Broadwater, who passed two lie detector tests to prove his innocence, said his life was devastated by his beliefs. After his sentence ended in 1999 and he was released from prison, he remained a public sex offender and was banished to friends, family and employers.

Feelings depicting Anthony Broadwater hugging relatives in court after a judge overturned rape convictions

Feelings depicting Anthony Broadwater hugging relatives in court after a judge overturned rape convictions

He was forced to do strange work and manual labor to get through, especially night shifts, and got an alibi in the event of another attack like Sebald’s midnight rape.

He said his wife Elizabeth wanted to have children, but he refused because he didn’t want the children to be stigmatized for his beliefs. And his alleged crime was visible to everyone.

In Sebald’s 1999 memoir, his accusator illustrated what happened to her as she returned home through a park near the college campus.

The 18-year-old was grabbed from behind, beaten, cut, and dragged into a bottling tunnel at the basement entrance of the amphitheater.

Sebald, a virgin, said the monster who raped her told her: “You are the worst b *** h I’ve done this.”

When he was done with her, he asked Sebald for her name. “I couldn’t lie. I had no other name than myself,” she said.

‘So his farewell words are:’ I’m glad to know you, Alice. .. .. See you in a while.

Author Alice Sebold, 58, Honorary Doctor of Humane Letters from Boston University in 2016

Author Alice Sebold, 58, Honorary Doctor of Humane Letters from Boston University in 2016

She immediately spoke to campus security and said she went to the police. Broadwater, then a 20-year-old US Marine Corps, was arrested five months later. After Sebald overtook the man, she was convinced that she was an attacker on the street.

“He was approaching and laughing. He recognized me,” she wrote lucky.

“It was a walk in the park for him. He met an acquaintance on the street.” Hey, girl, “he said. “Don’t you know you from somewhere?”

Sebald said she didn’t respond:’I saw him directly. I knew his face was above me in the tunnel.

She called police and arrested Broadwater, believed to have been seen in the area. However, after that, Sebald could not identify him in the police identification parade.

She wrote that she chose another man as the attacker. “The look on his eyes told me that if we were alone, if there was no wall between us, he would call me by name and kill me.”

Nevertheless, Broadwater was tried the following year. The results of the police lineup were mentioned in the trial, but when Sebald took the position of a witness, she identified the accused as her rapist.

Expert witnesses told the court that microscopic hair analysis linked Broadwater to crime. He was convicted of rape and sodomy and sentenced to eight to 25 years in prison.

The 2009 film adaptation of The Lovely Bones, directed by Peter Jackson, made a star from actress Saoirse Ronan, who played the protagonist Susie Salmon.

The 2009 film adaptation of The Lovely Bones, directed by Peter Jackson, made a star from actress Saoirse Ronan, who played the protagonist Susie Salmon.

Sebald, the daughter of a Spanish teacher, moved to New York and began drinking heroin while trying to establish herself as a writer as a waitress. She struggled to build a romantic relationship and found sex “clenching her teeth in a horrifying carnival ride that seems to be enjoyed by those around her.”

She was later determined to be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and was treated.

Her first novel, Lovely Bones, was published in 2002, three years after her little-interested memoirs, and quickly became a hit with sales of 5 million copies.

The story is told from the perspective of Susie Salmon, a 14-year-old girl. Susie Salmon speaks from heaven about being seduced by a neighbor, invited to an underground hideout, raped and killed.

Sebald admits that he might not have written Lovely Bourne without his experience of rape.

Following the success of the novel, Lucky was reissued and became a bestseller. In 2019, Lucky was also announced to be a feature film, but yesterday it was reported that the project was canceled a few months ago due to financial problems.

In the process of pre-production, executive producer Timothy Mucciante began to question the story behind it. “I started to question the second part of her book, the trial that wasn’t together, rather than the tragic story that Alice told about her assault,” he said. Told.

He was so skeptical that he left production in June and hired a private detective called Dan Myers to investigate the case. Based on his findings, Mucciante became convinced of Broadwater’s innocence.

Alice Sebold talks about the tragic experience of 1981 in her memoir Lucky, first published in 1998.

Alice Sebold talks about the tragic experience of 1981 in her memoir Lucky, first published in 1998.

His concerns were raised by a lawyer hired by Broadwater. Attorneys later argued in a court of appeal that the original trial relied on two unreliable evidences: Sebolt’s identification of Broadwater and hair evidence provided by a forensic chemist. They said both were flawed.

They said the fact that the writer first chose another man in the identity parade-he and Broadwater told the court that they looked like twins-was enough to raise prima facie suspicion.

For hair evidence, a forensic expert at the prosecution said in a trial that a sample of rapist’s hair found on her body “matched” Broadwater’s hair, but several others said. I couldn’t say if I had similar hair.

He even admitted that there was a “potential” that the hair could belong to someone other than the accused.

In 2016, then FBI Director James Comey admitted that in pre-1990s trials, “the emphasis was on hair comparisons over scientifically appropriate ones.”

“Hair isn’t like fingerprints because there are no studies showing how many people have hair fibers that look the same,” he added.

Broadwater’s current lawyer, David Hammond, was even more negative. “Sprinkling junk science on misidentification, it’s the perfect recipe for tort conviction.”

But he admitted that without proof of DNA, that is, if the evidence collected at that time no longer exists, no one can be sure.

Why did the man Alice Sebold help exempt the prisoner?Tom Leonard asks

Source link Why did the man Alice Sebold help exempt the prisoner?Tom Leonard asks

Back to top button