Judge appears skeptical of efforts to dismiss Dominion proceedings

Washington – A federal judge on Thursday dismisses a defamation proceeding filed by Dominion Voting Systems on an unfounded 2020 election claim by Trump’s allies Sidney Powell, Rudy Giuliani, and My Pillow Guy. He seemed skeptical of the argument.

Voting system companies have sued the trio for $ 1.3 billion each after claiming that the company had fraudulently elected Democrat Joe Biden. These allegations, along with falsehoods from former President Donald Trump and others, helped violent mobs attack the US Capitol on January 6, with failed efforts to thwart proof of Biden’s victory. I did.

The three continued to blame, even after both Republican and Democratic government officials and Trump’s own Attorney General said there was no evidence of widespread fraudulent voting. Dominion voting devices have been used in several major battlefield states.


On Thursday, Judge Karl Nichols of the US District Court heard a lawyer from Powell, Giuliani, and Minnesota-based CEO of My Pillow, Mike Lindell, arguing that the case should be dismissed. Lawyers argue that the speech is protected by the First Amendment, and that Dominion should be considered a government agency because it provided a voting device for elections and was treated like a public figure. Did. Also, in some cases, the lawyer states that the statement about Dominion is true and therefore not considered malicious.

Nichols told lawyers that the public debate over election security “is not the same as saying that a particular company intentionally voted fraudulently.”


Attorneys Powell and Giuliani, who challenged the election on behalf of Trump, and Lindel will switch votes as the voting machine company was founded in Venezuela to elect the late leader Hugo Chavez. .. Dominion also sued Fox News and the conservative media for the same allegations.

Dominion’s lawyer said the three had made deliberate and concrete false allegations aimed at defamation of the voting company, and the allegations continued after the failure of the legal allegations to challenge the election.

“These were statements made at press conferences, rallies, social media, and television … including just after the proceedings they referred to in court were dismissed,” said lawyer Tom Clare. ..


Powell and Lindel appeared in court. Giuliani, whose legal license was suspended in New York on Thursday after discovering that the panel had made false statements about the election, did not.

Elections confirmed by various election officials across the country, including Trump’s Attorney General William Barr, were free of widespread fraud. Republican governors in Arizona and Georgia, the major battlefield states essential to Biden’s victory, also guaranteed the integrity of elections in the state.

Almost all legal oppositions from Trump and his allies have been dismissed by judges, including two thrown by the Supreme Court, including three judges nominated by Trump.

The judge will decide at a later date.


Washington Associated Press author Nomaan Merchant contributed to this report.

Copyright 2021 AP communication. all rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.

Judge appears skeptical of efforts to dismiss Dominion proceedings

Source link Judge appears skeptical of efforts to dismiss Dominion proceedings

Back to top button