How Defective Investigation Leaves Texas COVID-19 Deaths Countless

Rick Hill, a retired high school principal, plays an important role in tracking down deaths associated with an ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.As a Justice of the Peace (JP) elected in Brazos County and a leader in Texas Justice of the Peace Association (JPCA), helping the virus determine how many Texas people were killed is part of his job. Hill spent decades as a science teacher before running for his position and is well known in the community for his time as a commentator on local soccer games. But he has no medical education.

All but 15 of Texas’s 254 counties rely on JP without a medical background. There is little training to respond to reports of homicide, suicide, or death at home, including those related to the coronavirus. However, during the pandemic, Hill said it would be difficult for a JP like him to determine whether to attribute his death at home to COVID-19, especially if test results were not available.In an interview, Hill Observer As JPCA president and state-wide mentor, he recently decided to exclude COVID-19 as the cause of death, even if the man who died was positive because of another JP’s history of alcohol abuse and liver damage. I advised. “For me, there is a difference between dying with COVID and dying with COVID,” Hill said. He admitted that doctors may have cited the virus as a contributor, especially since the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) says people with such an underlying condition are at high risk. In fact, Hill’s method is incompatible with recommendations from the JP Training Center in Texas and health authorities seeking a more complete count of deaths.

As of late March, state data count more than 47,000 COVID-19 deaths. However, COVID-19 deaths were dramatically understated last year in dozens of rural and suburban counties throughout Texas, according to ongoing studies of deaths reported nationally by researchers at Boston University School of Public Health. It seems to be evaluated. Other studies have previously suggested that in the first 6 months of the pandemic, 20-30% of deaths from COVID-19 nationwide may not have been reported. However, a new study based on CDC data from deaths reported at the county level in 2020 found that many rural and suburban counties in Texas and other states that depend on coroners or JP use health care. The coroner system suggests that it appears to have a much larger undercount compared to.

“Underreporting of COVID-19 was also high in areas with fewer hospitals, fewer COVID-19 tests, and more deaths at home,” the researchers write.

According to preliminary estimates, Brazos County is one of about 60 Texas County that is likely to have missed more than 25% of last year’s COVID-19-related deaths.In Brazos, CDC data show that only 155 of the 1,347 deaths reported in 2020 were due to COVID-19 by the physician and JP who approved the death certificate. However, according to a statistical model used by Boston researchers, the coronavirus may have contributed to more than 200 deaths in the county last year. This study compares reports of both COVID-19 deaths and all deaths reported nationally by county, and may be pandemic-related using past trends in deaths over the last decade. Estimate a sexual “excessive death”. These include deaths from COVID-19 as well as deaths associated with pandemics in other ways.

Last year, deaths increased across the United States. Nearly 300,000 more than expected The CDC reported that it died nationwide in 2020 as of October, based on the pattern of the previous year...

Andrew Stokes, principal researcher at Boston University, warned that undercounting individual counties is just an estimate, and the underlying reasons may vary from place to place. However, he said early results revealed widespread regional discrepancies in testing and diagnosing COVID-19, and that doctors and JP did not list COVID-19 as the cause of death certificates. It was.Stokes added it “Partisan differences can affect the likelihood that an individual will seek a COVID-19 test during his or her life, and whether the coroner and his offspring’s family will pursue a post-mortem test. I’m worried.Before the study His team investigated how underestimation changes depending on race and socioeconomic status.

Rebecca Fisher, an assistant professor of epidemiology at the University of Texas A & M and COVID-19 Task Force in Brazos County, underestimates deaths from COVID-19, so many Texas people test, contact trace, and then vaccine. He said he was concerned that it could be much less. , Than what you really need. “Ultimately, the reason we aggregate the data is to learn how to stop the pandemic and prevent this from happening in the future,” she said. “In this number, everyone is important.”

According to Boston University data Twenty-four counties in most parts of Texas may have missed more than half of their COVID-19 deaths in 2020. The statistical modeling used in this study predicts that the actual number of deaths directly or indirectly related to the pandemic in these counties may be two to four times higher than the official statistics. .. In Aransas County, which had the highest apparent undercount, According to last year’s death certificate, only 26 deaths were due to COVID-19. In contrast, Boston University researchers may have other reasons behind the reported increase in mortality, but the county probably missed as many as 90 additional excess mortality associated with COVID-19. It is estimated that there is a possibility. The county judge did not respond to the request for comment.

Some of the counties with the highest apparent undercounts are in East Texas, including Orange County and other more rural counties near the Louisiana border that reported some of the first Texas cases. Many of these deaths, according to Fisher, may have occurred in the spring of 2020, when they were quite difficult to test and the CDC did not share much information about the range of symptoms associated with the virus. The availability of tests across the state is a “very big problem with counting cases.”

JP in Orange County and Jefferson County last April Said Beaumont Enterprise They didn’t want to waste money ordering tests for people who were already dead, and they didn’t count deaths as COVID-19 deaths based on information provided by their families. JP Raychesson in Jefferson County He said he identified a “suspicious” case in which a symptomatological individual died on his way to the hospital but did not follow up on examination. “You’re not going to test the corpse,” he said. Chesson declined to request comment because he was being treated for cancer.

Philip Juan, a doctor who runs the Dallas County Public Health Department and heads the Texas Medical Association’s Public Health Commission, said the apparent undercount was because JP and private doctors would fill out death certificates accurately. It states that it means more training is needed. Resources can be properly deployed to address the major public health threats during and after the pandemic.

Texas law does not currently require JP medical training. The training program through the Criminal Appeals Court offers a two-hour course from the Inspector General when JP is elected on how to identify the cause of death. Thea Whalen, who organizes JP education as Secretary-General of the Texas Judiciary Court Training Center, organizes both initial training and continuing education for JP elected in Texas. Whalen said he advised JP to more actively list the deaths of COVID-19. That is, follow the CDC guidelines and list COVID-19 as the cause when confirmed by a test or when a family member explains the symptoms.

However, many people do not seem to follow that advice, making many data in Texas and the United States unreliable. “From now on, we need to pay more attention to the US mortality investigation system, including potential data quality issues related to the Coroner system,” concludes an early draft of Boston University’s research.

In Brazos County, Hill surveys about 100 deaths each year, including suicide and drug overdose, and last year surveyed several COVID-19 cases. Due to the large hospitals in Brazos County, Hill has fewer home deaths from COVID-19 than more rural areas, he said. For deaths in most hospitals, the doctor will identify the cause of death. However, JP confirms both deaths at home and deaths that occurred within 24 hours of arriving in the emergency room.

Hill does not disagree with Boston’s research and other findings that found COVID-19 deaths, suicides, drug overdose deficiencies and undercounts in the JP system. He knows that doctors will probably do a better job investigating deaths from COVID-19. But establishing a state-wide inspection system would be costly, he says.

He says that many JPs are at high risk for COVID-19 itself. For safety, Hill said he and many others had investigated some suspected COVID-19-related deaths over the phone. “We have a lot of JPs over the age of 65 and we run them remotely so we can keep them safer,” he said. “Obviously, if you have any questions about death, we will continue. To keep ourselves safe, we have a PPE bucket on the truck.”

How Defective Investigation Leaves Texas COVID-19 Deaths Countless

Source link How Defective Investigation Leaves Texas COVID-19 Deaths Countless

Back to top button