Texas

Draft opinions show the US Supreme Court revoking abortion rights

In a rare leak from the US Supreme Court, Politico reported that it had received a draft Supreme Court opinion showing the majority of the court in favor of repealing Roe’s landmark decision against Wade in 1973, which legalized abortion nationwide.

The document, marked as “1. Draft “by Judge Samuel Alito and distributed among other judges in February, represents a violation of the judges’ highly secretive discussion process, as their decisions are unknown until rulings have been made public.

These positions may change during the deliberation process, even after a majority opinion has been agreed, and a final ruling is expected before the Court concludes its current term in late June or early July.

At stake is the question of abortion rights in the United States, which since the Roe decision was nationally protected and reaffirmed in the 1992 case Planned Parenthood v. Casey.

A spokesman for the Supreme Court declined to comment.

Opinion polls show that the majority of the public in the United States is in favor of abortion being legal in most or all cases.

“If the Supreme Court actually gives a majority opinion in accordance with a leaked draft written by Judge Alito, the change in the soil patches of abortion rights will be as important as any other opinion issued by the court,” the American Civil Liberties Union said. Secretary-General Anthony Romero said in a statement late Monday: “It would deprive half the nation of the fundamental rights that have enjoyed the constitution that millions of women have enjoyed for over 50 years.

Alito is one of six conservative judges at the nine-member court, and it has long been the goal of social conservatives in the United States to overthrow Roe.

“Roe was very wrong from the start. Her reasoning was extremely weak and the decision has had detrimental consequences, “says the draft opinion.

The judges are taking a stand on the Dobbs case against the Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which includes the state of Mississippi’s ban on most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy.

The Federal Court of Appeals ruled in Mississippi that its time frame went against the standards set by Roe and Casey, which allow the mother to terminate the pregnancy without government intervention before the fetus is viable outside the womb.

The draft opinion rejects the restrictions on state power in Roe and Casey’s decisions, saying that state police should be the ones to decide what is legal in their state.

“Abortion is a deep moral question,” the draft said. “The Constitution does not prohibit citizens of any state from regulating or prohibiting abortion. Roe and Casey shouted over that power. We are now overturning these decisions and handing them over to the people and their elected representatives. ”

Politico said it had received a copy of the 98-page draft decision “from a party familiar with the Mississippi court’s proceedings, along with other information supporting the document’s authenticity.

Some information for this report came from the Associated Press and Reuters.

Draft opinions show the US Supreme Court revoking abortion rights

Source link Draft opinions show the US Supreme Court revoking abortion rights

Back to top button